Showing posts with label heart. Show all posts
Showing posts with label heart. Show all posts

Tuesday, June 12, 2012

Phun Physiology: Is excessive endurance exercise bad for the heart?


Maybe. This according to a study published this past week (June 4) in Mayo Clinic Proceedings by a team of cardiologists that bases its claims on a review of a number of animal and human studies.

Because the blogosphere was quick to pounce on the story (here, here, here, and here), I thought a short commentary might be appropriate. One that addresses the original article and whether it pertains to endurance cycling known as randonneuring.   

First of all, the researchers are not referring to daily, moderately intense workouts. Or to 2-3-mile runs four times a week. Nor are they referring to short intense interval workouts 2-3 times per week. In fact, the researchers acknowledge that these kinds of exercise regimens are extremely beneficial and may even add seven years to one’s life.

So what kind of activities does this particular team of cardiologists believe qualify as “excessive endurance exercise?” According to the article,   

[C]hronic training for and competing in extreme endurance events such as marathons, ultramarathons, ironman distance triathlons, and very long distance bicycle races . . .

Cycling? In an interview, the lead researcher, James O’Keefe, mentions the Tour de France and 200-mile bicycle races as examples of excessive endurance exercise.

Inferring from the article, it seems that for an endurance exercise regimen to qualify as “excessive,” it must be 1) almost daily, 2) hours at a time, 3) intense (racing), and 4) chronic (yearly).

The researchers have hypothesized that over time in some athletes excessive endurance exercise begins to remodel the heart in unhealthy ways. I’ve lifted the types of heart changes and their timelines from the article: 

. . . transient acute volume overload of the atria and right ventricle, with transient reductions in right ventricular ejection fraction and elevations of cardiac biomarkers, all of which return to normal within 1 week.

Over months to years of repetitive injury, this process, in some individuals, may lead to patchy myocardial fibrosis, particularly in the atria, interventricular septum, and right ventricle, creating a substrate for atrial and ventricular arrhythmias.

Additionally, long-term excessive sustained exercise may be associated with coronary artery calcification, diastolic dysfunction, and large-artery wall stiffening.

The phrase “patchy myocardial fibrosis, particularly in the atria” refers to tissue scarring in the heart’s two upper chambers—the atria. The heart’s electrical circuitry known as the pacemaker (SA-node) is located in the right atrium. Consequently, scarring there increases the likelihood of arrhythmias.

One type of arrhythmia known as atrial fibrillation can be particularly problematic, if not diagnosed and treated, since it can lead to sudden death. I shall say more about atrial fibrillation below.
  
It is important to note that the researchers view their thesis regarding the adverse cardiovascular effects of long-term excessive endurance exercise as tentative and that not all individuals may be susceptible to the aforementioned pathologies. In fact, the researchers note that “lifelong vigorous exercisers generally have low mortality rates and excellent functional capacity.”

It is extremely important to keep in mind that the occurrence of SCD [sudden cardiac death] during marathons, triathlons, and collegiate athletic events is rare and should not deter individuals from participating in vigorous ET [exercise training]; the benefits of regular PA [physical activity] to the individual and to society as a whole far outweigh potential risks. At the same time, long-term training for and competing in extreme endurance events may predispose to CV [cardiovascular] issues that are not seen in more moderate forms of PA.

Now the question: What does this study have to do with randonneuring? Nothing, unless randonneurs are also involved in daily, long-distance racing.  

But what about other studies? Of direct concern for randonneurs is the potential for atrial fibrillation, the chance of which increases in some individuals, who may have trained for but never competed in endurance-type races. This is the contention of Dr. Luis Mont, a Spanish physician, who 

reports that atrial fibrillation is more frequent in middle-aged individuals who formerly took part in competitive sports and continue to be active, or simply in those involved in regular endurance training without having actually participated in competitive sports.

Dr. Mont adds that

long-term endurance sport participation may well increase the incidence of cardiac arrhythmias, particularly atrial fibrillation, atrial flutter, sinus node dysfunction, and right ventricular premature beats.

Again, this pertains to a small proportion of the general population of endurance athletes. 

Here is a personal story—worth reading—of one cyclist who developed atrial fibrillation while on a bike ride and the outcome.

While many athletes use heart monitors as training aids, the usefulness of such devices extends well beyond training to include the detection of abnormal physiological states such as sudden spikes in heart rate—a possible sign of atrial fibrillation.

Should inexplicable heart-rate spikes occur in someone with whom you are riding, he or she should be strongly encouraged to get it checked out. Atrial fibrillation is something that is easily diagnosed and in many cases is treatable.
  
Be aware and be safe.

Let’s ride!

Update: Here is a link to Iron Rider, which has an important and related blogpost on atrial fibrillation in endurance athletes. 

Friday, November 14, 2008

Phun Physiology: Thought of a Heart Cramp Shouldn't Cramp Your Cycling



If you’ve ever experienced a leg cramp, you may have wondered if you could get a heart cramp. A leg cramp is one thing. But a heart cramp would be disastrous.

A search of “heart cramp” on the Internet reveals a few self-reporting individuals who are convinced they’ve experienced one. Even more amazing—they’ve lived to tell. We need to remind ourselves that self-diagnosis is tricky, hence the time-honored admonitions of seeking second opinions and physicians not treating themselves.

Repeating the Internet search, substituting highfalutin synonyms for heart cramp, “cardiac tetanus” and “cardiac tetany,” one is introduced to a world of medicalese.

The result? Great news for cyclists! The heart does not normally cramp unless one considers the administration of electrical shock or hypoparathyroidism normal. At least that is what biology and medical students are taught nowadays in the halls of academe.

Danesh and Dao at the UC-Davis School of Medicine assert: “Tetany is not possible in cardiac muscle because of the prolonged refractory period.” In the textbook I use in my human anatomy and physiology class, the authors Marieb and Hoehn write: “The long cardiac refractory period normally prevents tetanic contraction, which would stop the heart’s pumping action.”

For non-physiologists, refractory period is the time after a muscle cell is stimulated and contracts before it can be stimulated to contract again. Because skeletal muscle cells have a relatively short refractory period, constant or rapid-fire stimulation can cause nonstop whole-muscle contraction known variously as a cramp, tetanus, or tetany. But the long refractory period of cardiac muscle discourages tetany.

True—cardiac muscle can undergo tetany with the application of electrical shock, a phenomenon reported by Burridge in 1920 in an article entitled “Cardiac Tetanus” in the Journal of Physiology. But as long as cyclists don’t get zapped by lightning or step on downed electrical wires this shouldn’t be cause for worry.

Extremely low blood calcium levels can also cause muscle tetany. This is the connection with hypoparathyroidism and cardiac tetany. The parathyroid glands are stuck to the back of the larger thyroid gland. When blood calcium levels are too low to maintain proper nerve and muscle function, parathyroid hormone release restores calcium levels.

But hypoparathyroidism, or too little parathyroid hormone release, results in chronic low blood calcium levels, or hypocalcemia. This puts skeletal and cardiac muscle at increased risk for tetany. However, someone is more likely to experience hypocalcemic-induced neurological problems before experiencing muscle tetany.

Halpern and Wang make this point writing on the various health ailments associated with hypothyroidism: “Cardiac effects are limited because cardiac Tetany [sic] occurs at levels of hypocalcemia lower than those causing neurologic effects; therefore, the patient usually comes to medical attention prior to the onset of cardiac disturbances.” In other words, those suffering from hypothyroidism are likely to have non-cardiac-related health problems that would tend to curtail if not prevent cycling.

One hypocalcemic malady for example is the bone disease known as rickets. I am aware of articles in British Medical Journal and Indian Pediatrics which have reported the rare occurrence of cardiac tetany in children suffering from rickets.

It is important to note that heart cramps are not the same thing as either angina or heart attack. Any cyclist who senses some sort of chest discomfort should get checked posthaste by a medical expert competent to distinguish between heart burn and a true heart malady.

My purpose here is to assure cyclists that a leg cramp does not necessarily portend anything more sinister relating to the heart. Rather, leg cramps prevent further physical exertion. Leg cramps may also motivate cyclists to try to determine their possible cause.

My advice to cyclists? Don’t let the thought of a heart cramp slow you down.

Sunday, October 19, 2008

Phun Physiology: The Young at Heart, by Dean Furbish




The conversation in the parking lot at the conclusion of Saturday’s “Showdown in Black Creek” Permanent was delightfully animated (see Mike D's previous post). I mention this because we’d spent the day under overcast, melatonin skies and had battled a slight inbound headwind. No dreary moods here, though. The group of nine riders engaged in mild banter, self deprecation, and story-telling over coffee, pastry, and post-ride picture posing. It can be said that these riders are literally some of the young at heart. Read on.

The topic of this post occurred to me when a couple of riders shared hilarious anecdotes about how their normally slow heart rates had raised eyebrows during annual health checkups. Slow heart rates aside, it’s a fact that endurance training makes hearts young.

One indication of a “young” heart is its ability to metabolize glucose as an energy source during exercise. An aged heart loses its ability to utilize glucose during exercise. The good news is that endurance exercise reverses this aspect of aging.

Moreover, exercise benefits even the elderly, including those who previously have led inactive lives.

Exercise turns aged hearts into “young” hearts metabolically, according to a recent study out of Washington University School of Medicine in St. Louis, because it reverses the aged heart’s inability to metabolize glucose during exercise. In fact, exercise training enables the hearts of older people to double their glucose utilization during high-energy-demand exercise just like the hearts of younger people.

Women’s hearts benefit doubly metabolically as the result of endurance training. In addition to increasing cardiac glucose metabolism, it turns out that cardiac fatty acid metabolism increases as well in women. The same cannot be said for men.

I include some of the specifics of the 11-month study to point out that people do not need to be randonneurs or RAAM types or even train for years in order to obtain this anti-aging heart benefit of regular exercise.

In fact, endurance training was defined in the Washington University study as hour-long exercise sessions 3-5 times per week consisting of walking, running, or cycling. Participants began at 65% of maximum capacity for three months increasing to 75% for the next eight months. The six men and six women in the study were between the ages of 60 and 75. Although they were non-obese, participants had previously lived inactive lives.
Phun physiology advice: Keep riding!

The reference is here: Soto PF, Herrero P, Schechtman KB, Waggoner AD, Baumstark JM, Ehsani AA, Gropler RJ. Exercise training impacts myocardial metabolism of older individuals in a gender-specific manner. American Journal of Physiology. Heart and Circulatory Physiology. June 20, 2008 (advance online publication).